Can I Get a Refund for a Faulty Product in Australia? Major vs Minor Problems
Yes, if the problem is major: you choose a refund or a replacement, or keep the item and claim compensation for the drop in value. For a minor problem the business may choose to repair it free within a reasonable time. Store 'no refund' policies cannot remove these rights.
If a product you bought in Australia has a major problem, you are entitled to choose a refund or a replacement, or to keep it and get compensation for the drop in value. If the problem is minor, the business can choose to repair it free of charge instead, and you only get a refund or replacement if it cannot or will not fix it within a reasonable time. These rights come from the consumer guarantees in the Australian Consumer Law (ACL), which is Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010. A business cannot take them away with a "no refunds" sign, a store policy or its terms and conditions.
The consumer guarantees that apply to products
When a business sells you a product, the ACL guarantees, among other things, that it is of acceptable quality (safe, durable, free from defects and acceptable in appearance and finish), fit for any purpose you told the seller about, matches its description and any sample or demonstration model, and that any extra promises (express warranties) are honoured. There are also guarantees about spare parts and repairs being available for a reasonable time, and that you get clear title to the product.
The guarantees have no fixed expiry date such as "12 months". How long a product should last depends on what it is and what it cost. A dishwasher that costs several thousand dollars is expected to last longer than a cheap one. A manufacturer's warranty is on top of these rights, not instead of them, so a product can still fail the acceptable-quality guarantee after its warranty has run out.
Major or minor problem: why it matters
According to the ACCC, a product has a major problem if any one of these applies:
- it is unsafe;
- it is very different from the description or the sample;
- it has one serious problem, or several smaller problems, that would have stopped you buying it if you had known;
- it cannot be used for its normal purpose, or a purpose you told the seller about, and cannot easily be fixed within a reasonable time.
For a major problem, you choose: a refund, a replacement of the same type, or keeping the item with compensation for the drop in value. A refund should be the full price, without a deduction for use, and is normally paid in the same way you paid.
For a minor problem, the business chooses the remedy and must fix it free of charge. If it cannot or will not repair it within a reasonable time, you can have it repaired elsewhere and claim the reasonable cost, ask for a refund or replacement, or keep the product and claim compensation for the drop in value. In some cases you may also claim compensation for other damage and loss caused by the problem.
When you are not entitled to a remedy
The consumer guarantees do not give you a remedy if you simply changed your mind, found the product cheaper elsewhere, misused it, or knew about the problem before you bought it (for example, a marked-down item sold as damaged). A business may still offer a change-of-mind refund under its own policy, and if it does it must honour that policy.
The guarantees cover you as a consumer when you buy products normally bought for personal or household use, or anything costing less than $100,000 including GST. Most guarantees do not apply to private sales between individuals, such as garage sales or one-off online marketplace sales, or to traditional auctions run by the seller's agent. In those cases only the guarantees about title, undisturbed possession and no hidden debts apply.
Practical example
Amira buys a new washing machine for $1,100. Three weeks later the drum stops spinning and water floods the laundry. A machine that cannot wash clothes and leaks water is unsafe and cannot be used for its normal purpose, so this is likely a major problem. Amira can choose a refund or a replacement. The retailer tells her to "contact the manufacturer". That is not correct: the ACCC says businesses must not send consumers to the manufacturer instead of dealing with the problem themselves. Because the machine is large and installed, the retailer should arrange and pay for collection within a reasonable time. Amira may also be able to claim compensation for the damaged floor mat if the flood damaged it.
If the only fault had been a loose door handle that could be fixed quickly, that would likely be a minor problem and the retailer could choose to repair it.
How to ask for your remedy
- Stop using the product if it is unsafe, and keep it with any parts and packaging you still have.
- Find your proof of purchase. A receipt, bank or card statement, or order confirmation will usually do. You do not need the original packaging.
- Contact the business that sold it to you. Explain the problem, say whether you think it is major or minor, and say which remedy you want under the Australian Consumer Law.
- Return small items yourself and keep postage receipts. If a fault is confirmed, the business must repay reasonable return costs. For large, heavy or installed items the business should collect them.
- Put your request in writing if the first contact does not work, and give a clear deadline to respond.
- If the business still refuses, contact your state or territory consumer protection agency (for example, NSW Fair Trading or Consumer Affairs Victoria). You can also report the business to the ACCC, although the ACCC does not resolve individual disputes.
When to get legal advice
Get advice from a community legal centre or a lawyer if the problem has caused injury or significant property damage, if the amount is large (a car or a building product, for example), or if the business refuses to deal with you and you are thinking about applying to a state or territory tribunal or court. Small claims tribunals usually have strict time limits and filing fees, so check them early.