What happens when you file a consumer proposal in Canada?

A consumer proposal is a legally binding offer, made through a Licensed Insolvency Trustee, to pay unsecured creditors part of what you owe or over more time (up to five years). Total debts, not counting the mortgage on your home, must not exceed $250,000.

A consumer proposal is a formal offer to your creditors under the federal Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. You offer to pay a percentage of what you owe, to pay over a longer period, or both. The term cannot exceed five years. You can only make one through a Licensed Insolvency Trustee (LIT), who files it with the Office of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy (OSB). Once it is filed, you stop paying your unsecured creditors directly, and wage garnishments and lawsuits by those creditors are stopped. If the proposal is accepted and you complete it, you are released from the debts it covers and you keep your assets, as long as you keep paying your secured creditors.

Who can file a consumer proposal

A consumer proposal is for individuals whose total debts do not exceed $250,000. Debts secured by your principal residence, such as your mortgage, are not counted toward that limit. If you owe more, a consumer proposal is not available, and a trustee or lawyer can explain the alternatives.

Because bankruptcy and insolvency are federal law, the same consumer proposal rules apply in every province and territory. Where you live still matters for some related questions; for example, the OSB notes that how long the proposal stays on your credit report depends on your province.

How the process works, step by step

Meeting the trustee. The LIT reviews your income, expenses, assets and debts, explains your options and helps you work out an offer you can afford. You must give the trustee a complete list of your assets and debts.

Filing. The LIT files the proposal with the OSB and sends it to your creditors with a report on your financial situation. From the filing, payments go to the trustee, who distributes them to the creditors.

The creditors' decision. Creditors have 45 days after filing to accept or reject the proposal. A meeting of creditors is held only if creditors holding at least 25% of the total value of proven claims ask for one within those 45 days, or if the OSB directs the trustee to call one. A meeting that has been requested must be held within 21 days after it is called. If there is a meeting, the proposal is decided by a majority of the dollar value of the claims voting. The OSB gives this example: where proven claims total $150,000, creditors with at least $75,001 must accept.

Deemed acceptance. If no meeting is requested within the 45 days, the proposal is deemed accepted, even if some creditors object. Without a meeting, an objection is not a vote. If a meeting is called but there is no quorum, the proposal is also deemed accepted.

Court approval. After acceptance, the OSB or another interested party has 15 days to ask the trustee to apply to court for a review. If nobody asks, the court is deemed to have approved the proposal.

Counselling and payments. You must attend two financial counselling sessions, make the payments set out in the proposal and tell the trustee in writing if your address changes.

What happens if you miss payments

If your proposal calls for monthly payments, missing three payments means it is deemed annulled. If payments are less frequent, it is annulled once a payment is more than three months overdue. After annulment, creditors can again take steps to collect from you, unless the court orders otherwise or an amended proposal has been filed. An annulled proposal can be revived in some circumstances, so talk to your trustee immediately if you fall behind.

Debts a consumer proposal does not wipe out

An accepted and approved consumer proposal binds your unsecured creditors. Section 66.28(2.1) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, however, says it does not release you from the debts listed in section 178(1) of the Act, unless the proposal expressly compromises that particular debt and the creditor concerned voted to accept it. The debts in section 178(1) include:

  • fines, penalties and restitution orders imposed by a court for an offence;
  • spousal and child support under a court order or a maintenance agreement;
  • debts arising from fraud, embezzlement or misappropriation while acting as a fiduciary, and debts for property or services obtained by false pretences or fraudulent misrepresentation;
  • government student loans, where the insolvency happened while you were still a student or within seven years after you stopped being one;
  • awards of damages for intentionally inflicted bodily harm or sexual assault.

A co-signer or guarantor is also not released by your proposal (section 66.28(3)). If your sister co-signed your line of credit, the bank can still pursue her for the balance.

Practical example

Maya lives in Manitoba. She owes $62,000 on credit cards and a line of credit, plus a car loan secured on her vehicle, and her wages are being garnished. Her trustee proposes that she pay $300 a month for 60 months, a total of $18,000, to the unsecured creditors. When the proposal is filed, the garnishment stops. No creditor asks for a meeting within 45 days, so the proposal is deemed accepted, and 15 days later it is deemed approved by the court. Maya keeps her car because she keeps paying the car loan. When she makes the last payment, the trustee issues a certificate of full performance, which she sends to the credit reporting agencies.

Credit report and costs

The OSB says a consumer proposal generally gives you the lowest possible credit rating, and it stays on your credit report for the term of the proposal plus a few years, depending on your province. Once you have met all the terms, the trustee issues a certificate of full performance, and your credit can begin to rebuild. Before you sign, ask the trustee to explain in writing what the proposal will cost you in total, including the trustee's fees, and how much of your payments will reach the creditors.

When to get professional help

Get independent legal advice if you are being sued, if a creditor alleges fraud, if you owe large tax debts, if family support is involved or if you are close to the $250,000 limit. Check that the trustee is licensed by searching the OSB's database of Licensed Insolvency Trustees. Be cautious with anyone else who offers to arrange a proposal for a fee: only a Licensed Insolvency Trustee can prepare and administer a consumer proposal.

If your proposal is rejected, you can revise it and resubmit it, look at other options or consider bankruptcy.

Canada