Bought a Faulty Used Car From a Private Seller? What Your Rights Are

A private seller does not promise that a used car is of satisfactory quality, so 'buyer beware' largely applies. You still have a claim if the car does not match its description, if the seller misrepresented it, or if the seller had no right to sell it.

If you buy a used car from a private individual and it breaks down a week later, you have far fewer rights than if you had bought it from a dealer. The Sale of Goods Act 1979 only implies a promise that goods are of satisfactory quality and fit for purpose when the seller sells in the course of a business. A private seller gives no such promise. But you are not without protection: the car must still match its description, the seller must have the right to sell it, and you can claim if the seller gave you false information that persuaded you to buy.

Why a private sale is different from buying from a dealer

Section 14(1) of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 sets the starting point: apart from the rules in that section and section 15, there is no implied term about the quality or fitness for purpose of goods sold. Section 14(2), which implies that goods are of satisfactory quality, and section 14(3), which covers fitness for a purpose you made known, apply only "where the seller sells goods in the course of a business". The stronger consumer rights in the Consumer Rights Act 2015, such as the 30-day right to reject, apply only when you buy from a trader.

In practice this means that a worn clutch, a tired gearbox or a fault that appears after the sale is usually your risk when you buy privately, unless one of the rules below applies. Before you rely on the private-sale rules, check whether the seller was really a private person. Someone who buys and sells cars regularly to make money, or a dealer posing as a private seller, may be selling in the course of a business, and then the full trader rules apply.

The protections that do apply in a private sale

The car must match its description. Section 13 of the Sale of Goods Act 1979 implies a term that goods sold by description will correspond with that description. Unlike section 14, it is not limited to business sellers. If the advert or the seller described the car as a particular model, engine size, year, mileage or as having a full service history, and that turns out to be untrue, you may have a claim. In England, Wales and Northern Ireland this term is a condition, which can allow you to reject the car as well as claim damages.

The seller must have the right to sell. Section 12 implies that the seller has the right to sell the car and that it is free from any charge or encumbrance you were not told about. If the car turns out to be stolen or still owned by a finance company, the seller is in breach. There is a specific protection in section 27 of the Hire Purchase Act 1964 (England, Wales and Scotland): a private buyer who buys a car in good faith without notice that it is subject to a hire purchase or conditional sale agreement can obtain good title even though the seller did not own it outright.

The seller must not mislead you. If the seller made a false statement of fact that led you to buy, such as "it has never been in an accident" or "the cambelt was changed last year", that can be a misrepresentation. In England and Wales, section 2(1) of the Misrepresentation Act 1967 makes the person who made it liable for damages unless they prove they had reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe, that the statement was true. A court can also set the contract aside or award damages instead under section 2(2). Northern Ireland has its own equivalent legislation, and Scotland applies its own law of misrepresentation, so get local advice there.

Does "sold as seen" stop you from claiming?

Not completely. Private sellers often write "sold as seen" or "no warranty" on the receipt. The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 limits what such a clause can do, and section 6(4) makes clear that it covers private sales as well as business sales:

  • Liability for the seller's right to sell under section 12 cannot be excluded or restricted at all (section 6(1) for England, Wales and Northern Ireland; section 20(1) for Scotland, where such a term is void).
  • Liability for the description term in section 13 can be excluded only in so far as the term satisfies the requirement of reasonableness (section 6(1A)), or in Scotland only if it was fair and reasonable to include it (section 20(1A)).
  • In England and Wales, a clause excluding liability for misrepresentation has no effect unless it is reasonable, and it is for the seller to show that it is (Misrepresentation Act 1967, section 3).

A "sold as seen" clause therefore helps a private seller mainly against complaints about general condition and wear, which a private seller never promised anyway. It is unlikely to protect a seller who described the car wrongly or lied about it.

Safety: an unroadworthy car

Section 75 of the Road Traffic Act 1988, which applies in England, Wales and Scotland, makes it an offence for any person, not only a trader, to sell or offer to sell a vehicle in an unroadworthy condition, for example with defective brakes, steering or tyres, or in a state where using it would involve a danger of injury. A private seller has a defence if they prove they had reasonable cause to believe the car would not be used on a road in Great Britain until it was made roadworthy. Section 75(7) says the offence does not by itself affect the validity of the contract, so this is a criminal matter rather than an automatic right to your money back, but it is relevant if the seller hid a dangerous fault.

Practical example

Priya buys a five-year-old hatchback from a private seller in Leeds for £4,500. The advert says "one owner, full service history, 48,000 miles". Two weeks later the garage finds that the service book was filled in with false stamps and the MOT history on GOV.UK shows the car had 92,000 miles at an earlier test. The receipt says "sold as seen". Priya can argue that the car did not match its description (section 13) and that the seller misrepresented the mileage and history. The "sold as seen" wording is unlikely to be reasonable as a way of excusing a false description. If the gearbox had simply failed with no false statement, she would most likely have no claim against a private seller.

What to do if the car is faulty

Act quickly and keep evidence. Gather the advert (take screenshots before it is deleted), messages with the seller, the receipt, the V5C and any garage report. Write to the seller explaining what was described, what is wrong and what you want: taking the car back and refunding you, or paying for the cost of repair or the difference in value. Give a clear deadline.

If the seller refuses, you can go to court. In England and Wales you can apply to a county court for money owed, online or by post, and the court may offer mediation first. In Scotland, claims of £5,000 or less for payment of money use the simple procedure in the sheriff court. In Northern Ireland, the small claims process covers claims of not more than £5,000. The court will look closely at what was said and written before the sale, so your evidence matters more than anything else.

When to get a lawyer

Get advice from a solicitor or an advice service if the car is worth a lot, if it turns out to be stolen or subject to finance, if you suspect the seller is a trader pretending to be private, if someone was injured because of a dangerous fault, or if the seller has started court action against you. A solicitor can also tell you whether rejecting the car or claiming damages is the better route in your part of the UK.

United Kingdom