Can I get a refund for faulty goods in Ireland, or must I accept a repair?
If goods you bought from a business in Ireland turn out to be faulty within 30 days of getting them, you can reject them for a full refund. After 30 days the business must first repair or replace them free of charge; a refund or price cut follows if that fails or the fault is serious.
If something you bought from a shop or website in Ireland is faulty, the Consumer Rights Act 2022 gives you a clear ladder of remedies. Within 30 days of getting the goods you can end the contract and get a full refund (the "short-term right to terminate"). After that, you can choose a free repair or replacement, and if the business refuses, fails or the fault is serious, you can ask for a price reduction or a refund (the "final right to terminate"). Your claim is against the business that sold you the goods, not the manufacturer.
What counts as "faulty"
The Act does not use the word faulty. It says the trader must deliver goods that are in conformity with the sales contract at the "relevant time" (section 15). Goods are not in conformity if, for example, they do not match the description, do not work as goods of that kind normally would, are not of the quality and durability you could reasonably expect, or are missing accessories or instructions (sections 17 and 18). Incorrect installation by the trader also counts (section 19).
The relevant time is usually the moment you, or someone you nominated, take physical possession of the goods (section 15(4)). For online orders, that is generally when the parcel is delivered to you, not the order date.
These rules apply when you buy as a consumer from a trader. They do not cover a private sale between two individuals, such as buying a second-hand bike from a neighbour.
Within 30 days: the short-term right to terminate
Under section 24, you have 30 days from the relevant time to exercise the short-term right to terminate. If the trader has to install the goods or do something else before you can use them, the 30 days start when that is finished (section 24(2)(a)). For goods that can be expected to go off or deteriorate sooner, such as fresh food or flowers, the period is shorter, and in a dispute the trader must show that a shorter period applies (section 24(4) and (5)).
To use the right, you make a statement to the trader that you are ending the contract and return the goods at the trader's expense (section 28(2)). The trader must then refund the price and any costs you had in returning the goods (section 30(2)). Under section 31 the refund must be made without undue delay and no later than 14 days after the trader receives the goods back (or your evidence of returning them), using the same payment method unless you agree otherwise, and without any fee.
The Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC) puts it simply: within the first 30 days, you do not need to accept a repair if the product is faulty. Act quickly, because you must tell the business within the 30-day period.
After 30 days: repair or replacement first
Once the 30 days have passed, section 23 lets you choose between repair and replacement. The trader can refuse your choice only if it is impossible or would cost the trader disproportionately more than the other option. Under section 25, the repair or replacement must be:
- free of charge, which section 10 defines as including postage, carriage, labour and materials;
- carried out within a reasonable time, meaning the shortest time objectively needed;
- done without significant inconvenience to you.
The trader must collect or take back the goods at its own expense, and you do not have to pay for normal use of goods that are replaced (section 25(5) and (7)). If installed goods have to be removed, the trader must remove and reinstall them or pay for that work (section 25(6)).
When you can get a price reduction or a refund after 30 days
Section 26 gives you the choice of a proportionate price reduction or the final right to terminate (a refund) where:
- the trader refused to repair or replace, or did not complete it properly;
- the same or a new fault appears despite the trader's attempt to fix it;
- the fault is so serious that it justifies an immediate price reduction or termination; or
- the trader has said, or it is clear, that it will not fix the goods within a reasonable time or without significant inconvenience.
You cannot use the final right to terminate for a minor fault, but in a dispute it is for the trader to prove the fault is minor (section 26(3) and (4)). On a final termination, the refund can be reduced only for depreciation beyond what normal use would cause, and again the trader must prove that (section 30(3) and (4)).
If you have not paid the full price yet, for example you paid a deposit, section 32 lets you withhold the outstanding balance in proportion to the fault until the trader delivers conforming goods. You must tell the trader you are doing so.
The 12-month presumption and the six-year period
If a fault becomes apparent within 12 months of the relevant time, it is presumed to have existed at that time unless the trader proves otherwise, or the presumption does not fit the nature of the goods or the fault (section 22(1)). You only need to show that the goods do not conform and that this became apparent within the 12 months (section 22(3)). After 12 months you can still claim, but you have to show the fault was there from the start, for example with an independent expert's report.
The CCPC explains that your rights to a repair, replacement or refund last for up to six years from the day you bought the product or it was delivered, as long as the product could reasonably be expected to last that long. A warranty or guarantee is extra and does not replace these rights, so a business cannot refuse to help just because the warranty has expired.
Practical example
Aoife buys a washing machine online and it is delivered and installed on 3 March. On 20 March it starts leaking. She is within 30 days of installation, so she emails the retailer stating that she is terminating the contract under the short-term right. The retailer must collect the machine at its expense and refund the full price, including any delivery charge, within 14 days of getting it back.
If the leak had started in October, she would ask for a free repair or replacement. If the repair failed and the machine leaked again, she could then choose a price reduction or a refund under section 26.
What to do now
- Contact the business that sold you the goods as soon as you notice the fault, by phone, in store or by email.
- State clearly which remedy you want and which right you rely on: the 30-day right to terminate, repair or replacement, or a price reduction or refund.
- Put it in writing and keep copies, photos of the fault, your proof of purchase and the delivery date.
- If the business will not resolve it, send a formal written complaint. The CCPC also mentions a chargeback through your card provider and, for claims of €2,000 or less, the small claims procedure.
When to get legal advice
Talk to a solicitor or get advice if the goods are expensive (such as a car or a kitchen), if the trader disputes that a fault exists and you need expert evidence, if the goods were bought on hire purchase or with finance, if the seller is outside Ireland, or if the purchase was made before 29 November 2022, when different rules apply.