Bought a faulty used car from a private seller? Your rights in New Zealand
Private car sales are not covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act or the Fair Trading Act. You may still cancel or claim compensation under the Contract and Commercial Law Act if the seller had no right to sell, the car did not match the description or the seller misled you.
If you bought a used car from a private seller in New Zealand and it turns out to be faulty, the Consumer Guarantees Act and the Fair Trading Act generally do not help you, because private sales are not covered by them. Your rights come from the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017 (CCLA) and the general law of contract. You may be able to cancel the sale or claim compensation if the seller had no right to sell the car, the car did not match the description, or the seller made a serious false statement that persuaded you to buy it. If you cannot agree with the seller, you can take a claim to the Disputes Tribunal.
Which laws apply to a private car sale
Consumer Protection (MBIE) explains that private sales "aren't covered by the Consumer Guarantees Act or the Fair Trading Act". There is no automatic guarantee that a privately sold car is of acceptable quality, durable or fit for purpose. You buy it as seen, including flaws and wear and tear.
What does apply are the CCLA warranties:
- Title: the seller must have good title, meaning the right to sell the car.
- Description: the car must match the description the seller gave, or the sample shown.
- Misrepresentation: if the seller made a false or misleading statement, the statement was serious, and you were persuaded to buy because of it, you may be able to cancel the contract or claim compensation.
A seller can exclude the CCLA warranties in the contract at the time of sale, for example with wording such as "no other warranties either express or implied by law". But an "as is, where is" sale does not protect a seller who knew about serious faults or a debt on the car and kept quiet about it.
When the seller is really a dealer
Some people who advertise privately are in fact traders. Consumer Protection notes that someone who sells more than six vehicles a year, or imports more than three, may be a motor vehicle trader. If so, the Consumer Guarantees Act applies and you have much stronger rights. Be alert if the seller is selling several cars at once.
Money owing on the car
If there is a registered security interest over the car, a finance company may be able to repossess it even though you did not know about the debt. A search of the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR) before you buy shows whether money is owed. If the seller told you the car was debt-free and it was not, that may be misrepresentation.
A practical example
Aroha buys a 2015 hatchback privately for $9,000 after the seller writes in the listing "no mechanical issues, timing belt done last year". Two weeks later the engine fails, and a mechanic finds that the timing belt is the original one. The statement in the listing was specific and false, and it influenced her decision. Aroha writes to the seller with the mechanic's report and asks to cancel the sale and get her money back. If the seller refuses, she can apply to the Disputes Tribunal for cancellation and a refund, or for compensation.
Steps to take
- Stop using the car if it is unsafe.
- Gather evidence early: the listing, messages, receipts, photos and an inspection report.
- Write to the seller describing the problem and what you want: cancellation with a full or partial refund, compensation, or another agreed fix.
- Go to the Disputes Tribunal if you cannot agree. It is quicker and cheaper than court and lawyers do not represent the parties. You need the seller's name and address to make a claim.
Do not forget the change of ownership
Both buyer and seller must notify Waka Kotahi NZ Transport Agency of the change of ownership. Consumer Protection advises the buyer to do this within seven days to avoid fines or infringements, and the easiest way is online on the spot. Keep your own record of the date and time the car changed hands.
When to get legal advice
Get advice from a Community Law Centre, Citizens Advice Bureau or a lawyer if a finance company threatens to repossess the car, if the amount at stake is large, or if the seller says the contract excluded all warranties. This article explains the general rules and does not replace advice on your situation.