Dismissed in Pakistan? How to file a grievance with your employer and the NIRC

If an employer in Islamabad or with branches in more than one province dismisses you, send a written grievance within 90 days. If it does not reply within 15 days (7 via your union) or you disagree, file with the NIRC within 60 days.

If you were dismissed or denied a legal right by an employer in the Islamabad Capital Territory, or by a company with branches in more than one province, you can challenge it through a written grievance and then a case before the National Industrial Relations Commission (NIRC). The key deadlines are short: you must give your employer a written grievance within 90 days of the cause arising, and if the employer does not answer in time or you are not satisfied, you must take the matter to the NIRC within 60 days. Missing these dates can cost you the case.

Does the federal procedure apply to you?

The procedure comes from section 33 of the Industrial Relations Act 2012. Section 1(3) of that Act says it applies to everyone employed in an establishment or industry in the Islamabad Capital Territory, or in an establishment carrying on business in more than one province. The Act calls such an employer "trans-provincial": an establishment or group of establishments with branches in more than one province.

The Act does not apply to everyone. Section 1(3) excludes, among others, people employed in the police and defence services, in the administration of the State (other than those employed as workmen), and in institutions caring for the sick, infirm or destitute that are not run on a commercial basis.

You must also be a "worker" or "workman" under section 2(xxxiii). That covers anyone employed for hire or reward, directly or through a contractor, including supervisors and apprentices, whether the terms are written or not. It does not include a person employed mainly in a managerial or administrative capacity. Job titles alone do not decide this; what matters is the work you actually do.

If you work for a single-province employer, your grievance goes under that province's own industrial relations law to the provincial Labour Court. In Sindh, for example, Standing Order 16(3) of the Sindh Terms of Employment (Standing Orders) Act 2015 says that a worker aggrieved by termination, removal, retrenchment, discharge or dismissal may act under section 37 of the Sindh Industrial Relations Act 2013, which applies as it does to an individual grievance.

Step 1: the written grievance to your employer (90 days)

Under section 33(1), a worker may bring a grievance about any right guaranteed or secured by law, an award or a settlement to the employer's notice in writing. You can do this yourself or through your shop steward or collective bargaining agent (CBA). It must be done within ninety days of the day on which the cause of the grievance arises. For a dismissal, that is normally the date of the dismissal order.

The employer then has a fixed time to reply in writing:

  • If you sent the grievance yourself, the employer must communicate its decision in writing within 15 days (section 33(2)).
  • If the grievance came through your shop steward or CBA, the employer must reply within 7 days (section 33(3)).

Keep proof of delivery, such as a receipt stamped by the employer's office, a courier receipt or a registered post slip. The date matters for the next deadline.

Step 2: taking the case to the NIRC (60 days)

Section 33(4) lets you take the matter to the Commission if the employer does not reply within the time limit, or if you are not satisfied with its decision. The proviso sets the deadline: you must go to the Commission within sixty days of the employer's written decision or, if no decision came, within sixty days of the end of the 15-day or 7-day reply period.

The Act directs the Commission to give a decision within seven days of the matter being brought before it, treating it as if it were an industrial dispute. The law expects a fast decision. Workers with a common grievance arising out of the same cause of action, for example a group laid off on the same day, may make a joint application (section 33(8)).

Under section 33(5), the Commission must go into all the facts and pass such orders as are just and proper. Regulation 59(2) of the NIRC (Procedure and Functions) Regulations 2016 gives it power to summon the employer, call witnesses and examine them on oath, and order documents to be produced. If a party does not appear after notice, the Commission may decide the case ex parte. Where the case arises out of a dismissal or removal from service, the Commission may direct reinstatement and allow consequential benefits.

What happens after the decision

An order in your favour has teeth. If a decision or order under section 33 is not complied with within seven days, or within the period the order sets, the defaulter can be punished with imprisonment of up to one year, a fine of up to seventy-five thousand rupees, or both (section 33(6)). A prosecution needs a written complaint by the worker or by the Commission (section 33(7)).

Either side can appeal. Under section 58, a person aggrieved by an award or decision of a Bench may appeal to the Commission within thirty days; the appeal is heard by the Full Bench. In an appeal against an order of reinstatement, the Full Bench may stay that order, but it must then decide the appeal within twenty days, or the stay lapses.

Separately, the Payment of Wages Act 1936 requires that when an employer terminates your employment, the wages you earned are paid before the end of the second working day after termination (section 5(2)). Unpaid final wages can be part of your claim.

A practical example

Bilal worked as a supervisor at the Rawalpindi branch of a courier company that also has offices in Karachi and Peshawar. On 3 March he received a letter ending his job with immediate effect. Because the company has branches in several provinces, the Industrial Relations Act 2012 applies. Bilal sends a written grievance to the company's head office on 20 March, well within 90 days, and keeps the courier receipt. The company does not reply within 15 days. Bilal now has 60 days from the end of that 15-day period to file with the NIRC. He files his petition with copies of his appointment letter, salary slips, the termination letter, his grievance and the courier receipt, and asks for reinstatement with back benefits.

When to get a lawyer

The procedure is designed so that workers can use it, often with the help of a union. Still, get advice from a labour lawyer or your CBA if:

  • your employer says you are a manager and not a "worker";
  • you are unsure whether your employer is trans-provincial or the provincial law applies;
  • a deadline has already passed or is about to pass;
  • you were dismissed for alleged misconduct after an inquiry; or
  • the employer appeals an order in your favour.

The NIRC website publishes the Industrial Relations Act 2012, its procedural regulations, the forms used before it, and judgments from its benches in Islamabad, Lahore and Karachi. Reading a few judgments on similar facts is a good way to see how the Commission approaches dismissal cases.

Pakistan