Consumer Review Fairness Act: Illegal Review-Suppression Clauses

The Consumer Review Fairness Act restricts standardized contract terms that silence honest reviews, penalize reviewers, or seize review IP rights, while preserving defined exceptions.

Jurisdiction

United States — federal law governing specified provisions in form contracts, with state consumer-protection and defamation law overlays.

What the Act protects

The Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA) protects an individual's ability to share honest opinions about a seller's goods, services, or conduct. It targets standardized contract terms that businesses may be tempted to use to silence or punish negative reviews.

The Act generally makes covered form-contract provisions void from inception when they prohibit or restrict a consumer's covered review, impose a penalty or fee because of such a review, or require the consumer to transfer intellectual-property rights in review content.

A prohibited clause can be a problem even before enforcement

A business should not assume it is safe to include a non-disparagement or review-ownership clause merely because it has never sued a customer. Federal enforcement can focus on offering or using the prohibited form term itself.

The law has limits

The CRFA does not protect every communication. It preserves the ability to address content that is confidential or private, defamatory, harassing, obscene, unrelated to the seller's goods or services, clearly false or misleading, or otherwise within statutory exceptions. It also does not prevent a platform from establishing lawful content rules.

The distinction between an honest negative opinion and an actionable false factual statement can be state-law dependent. Businesses should avoid using groundless legal threats to suppress criticism; separate FTC rules also address review suppression.

Contract audit

Review website terms, checkout terms, service agreements, memberships, releases, settlement forms, employee-created customer forms, and any clause concerning reviews, publicity, social media, confidentiality, liquidated damages, or ownership of user content.

A legitimate confidentiality clause should be narrowly connected to protected information rather than written so broadly that consumers would reasonably understand it to prohibit honest performance reviews.

Enforcement

The FTC and state attorneys general can enforce the CRFA, and knowing violations can carry financial consequences under the statutory framework. The FTC Act and the separate Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule can also apply to review practices.

This is general legal information. It does not decide whether a specific statement is protected or defamatory.

United States