E-Verify: Employer Duties, Timing, and Mismatch Rights

E-Verify basics: it supplements rather than replaces I-9, cannot be used for pre-screening, participating employers follow case timing rules, and employees have rights when a DHS/SSA mismatch occurs.

Jurisdiction

United States — federal employment-eligibility verification program. E-Verify is voluntary for most employers under federal law, but federal-contract rules and state or local laws can require participation in specified circumstances.

E-Verify does not replace Form I-9

E-Verify electronically compares information from Form I-9 against records available to the Department of Homeland Security and Social Security Administration. Participating employers still must complete Form I-9.

E-Verify's own guidance distinguishes the two systems: Form I-9 is mandatory for covered hires, while E-Verify is voluntary for most employers. Federal contractors with a covered FAR clause and employers subject to certain state requirements may have different participation duties.

Do not pre-screen applicants

Participating employers may not use E-Verify to screen applicants before hire. Current E-Verify guidance requires employers to create cases for covered new hires after Form I-9 completion and generally no later than the third business day after the employee starts work for pay.

Selective verification based on citizenship, immigration status, national origin, appearance, accent, or perceived foreignness is prohibited. Participating hiring sites must follow the program rules consistently.

Tentative Nonconfirmation — mismatch

A DHS or SSA Tentative Nonconfirmation, now commonly described as a mismatch, does not necessarily mean the employee lacks work authorization. It can arise from a name change, data-entry error, outdated agency record, status update, or other discrepancy.

The employer must follow the current Further Action Notice process, privately notify the employee, and give the employee the opportunity to decide whether to take action. E-Verify currently states that the employer and employee have a 10-federal-government-working-day process for the employee's decision after a mismatch is issued.

No adverse action while a mismatch is being properly contested

Employers must follow E-Verify's rules and may not take prohibited adverse action merely because of a tentative mismatch while the employee is timely pursuing the resolution process.

Privacy

E-Verify data contains sensitive personally identifiable information. Access should be limited to authorized users and records should be stored and handled consistently with program requirements.

This page is general compliance information. A final case result, disputed employment authorization, federal-contract clause, or state mandate should be reviewed against current DHS rules.

United States