ERISA Health Benefit Claims and Appeals: Federal Basics

ERISA health-claim basics: SPDs, denial notices, the general 180-day appeal opportunity, full-and-fair review, administrative records, exhaustion, and possible external review.

Jurisdiction

United States — federal employee-benefits law. ERISA generally governs many private-sector employee benefit plans, but government plans and many church plans are treated differently. State insurance law and Affordable Care Act protections may also apply.

Start with the plan documents

A participant in an ERISA-covered health plan should begin with the Summary Plan Description (SPD), Summary of Benefits and Coverage, and the plan's claims procedure. These documents describe covered benefits, exclusions, who decides claims, how to appeal, and where to send submissions.

A denial must explain the decision

Federal claims-procedure rules require plans to provide specified information when a benefit claim is denied, including reasons for the decision and information about appeal rights. The details and decision deadlines vary by claim type, including urgent-care, pre-service, and post-service health claims.

Appeal rights

DOL's current worker guide states that a claimant generally has at least 180 days to appeal a denied group-health claim. The plan must provide a full and fair review and, on request, generally provide relevant claim records without charge. Appeal review deadlines depend on the type of health claim.

A participant should not treat the appeal as a short informal complaint. The administrative record can become important if litigation later occurs, so relevant medical records, plan language, factual explanations, expert material, and other support should be submitted within the permitted process.

Exhaustion and court review

DOL guidance explains that claimants normally must complete the plan's claims process before asking a court to review a denial. Exceptions or different rules can apply where a plan fails to establish or follow compliant procedures, and judicial limitation periods may arise from the plan or other law.

External review and other protections

Depending on the plan and claim, Affordable Care Act external-review rules or state external-review procedures may also be relevant. Those procedures are distinct from the ordinary internal appeal.

Preserve every notice

Keep the SPD, benefit booklet, denial letter, appeal submission, medical records, correspondence, proof of delivery, and the final appeal decision. A missed plan or court deadline can be difficult to repair.

This guide is general legal information and does not determine whether a particular medical service is covered.

United States