Collective Bargaining Under the NLRA: Good-Faith Bargaining Basics

Federal good-faith bargaining basics: mandatory subjects, no duty to make concessions, information duties, unilateral-change risk, contract expiration, impasse, and NLRB timing.

Jurisdiction

United States — federal private-sector labor law. Public-sector bargaining, rail and airline labor relations, and other excluded workplaces use different legal regimes.

The bargaining duty

When employees have a lawfully recognized or certified representative, the NLRA generally requires the employer and union to meet at reasonable times and bargain in good faith over wages, hours, and other mandatory terms and conditions of employment.

NLRB guidance identifies subjects such as pay, hours, insurance, safety practices, seniority, grievance procedures, discipline, layoff and recall as common mandatory bargaining subjects. Whether a particular operational decision is itself mandatory can be a complex question.

Good faith does not mean forced agreement

Federal law does not require either side to accept a proposal or make a concession. Parties can bargain hard. The legal question is whether their overall conduct satisfies the statutory duty to bargain in good faith.

Conduct potentially inconsistent with that duty can include a flat refusal to meet, surface bargaining without genuine intent to reach agreement, unilateral changes to mandatory subjects when bargaining is required, refusal to provide relevant information required for bargaining, or direct dealing that improperly bypasses the representative. Each issue is fact-specific.

Contract expiration does not erase every duty

NLRB guidance states that after a collective-bargaining agreement expires, the parties generally continue to have a bargaining duty, and many existing terms and conditions cannot simply be changed unilaterally while bargaining obligations continue. Exceptions and distinctions apply, including to contractual provisions that do not survive expiration.

Impasse is a legal conclusion

A genuine bargaining impasse can affect what an employer may lawfully do, but simply declaring “impasse” does not create one. Bargaining history, number and quality of meetings, importance of disputed issues, movement in proposals, and the parties' conduct can matter.

Charges have a short general filing period

NLRB unfair-labor-practice charges generally must be filed within six months. Live negotiations therefore require current, case-specific advice.

This page is general legal information and is not bargaining strategy or advice concerning a specific labor dispute.

United States