Can I return faulty goods within six months and demand a refund in South Africa?

Yes. Under section 56(2) of the Consumer Protection Act you may return defective goods to the supplier within six months of delivery, at the supplier's risk and expense, and you – not the shop – choose repair, replacement or a refund.

If goods you bought from a business turn out to be defective within six months of delivery, the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 (CPA) lets you take them back. Section 56(2) says the consumer may return the goods to the supplier "without penalty and at the supplier's risk and expense", and the supplier must, "at the direction of the consumer", either repair or replace them, or refund the price paid. The choice is yours. The National Consumer Commission (NCC) confirmed this in its Explanatory Note 7 of 2023: a shop may offer a repair, but you are not bound to accept that offer if you have chosen a refund.

What the rule says

The six-month right is tied to the quality standard in section 55 of the CPA. Under section 55(2), every consumer has the right to receive goods that:

  • are reasonably suitable for the purposes for which they are generally intended;
  • are of good quality, in good working order and free of any defects;
  • will be usable and durable for a reasonable period of time, given how they would normally be used; and
  • comply with any applicable standards under the Standards Act or other public regulation.

If you told the supplier about a specific purpose (for example, that you need a pump for a borehole of a certain depth) and the supplier ordinarily sells such goods or acted as if it knew about them, the goods must also be reasonably suitable for that purpose (section 55(3)).

Section 56(1) adds an implied warranty: the producer or importer, the distributor and the retailer each warrant that the goods meet the section 55 standard. Section 55(5)(a) makes it irrelevant whether the defect was hidden or visible, or whether you could have spotted it before taking delivery.

If you choose a repair and, within three months after that repair, the same problem has not been fixed or a new defect appears, section 56(3) says the supplier must then replace the goods or refund the price.

Who the rule applies to – and when it does not

The CPA protects consumers in transactions with a supplier acting in the ordinary course of business. It therefore covers purchases from shops, dealers and online stores in South Africa, but generally not a once-off sale between two private people, for example a used item bought from a neighbour.

Important limits:

  • Goods sold "as is" with your express agreement. Section 55(6) says the suitability and good-quality rules in section 55(2)(a) and (b) do not apply if you were expressly told the goods were offered in a specific condition and you expressly agreed to accept them in that condition (or knowingly acted as if you did). A general "voetstoots" line in small print is not the same as being specifically told about a condition.
  • Auctions. Section 55(1) excludes goods bought at an auction.
  • Altered goods. The implied warranty does not apply to the extent that the goods were altered contrary to the instructions, or after leaving the control of the supplier (section 56(1)).
  • Large businesses as buyers. The Act does not apply where the consumer is a juristic person whose asset value or annual turnover equals or exceeds the threshold set by the Minister (section 5(2)(b)).
  • Credit agreements. A credit agreement itself falls under the National Credit Act, but the goods bought on credit are still covered by the CPA (section 5(2)(d)).
  • Normal wear and misuse. Goods that are worn out through ordinary use after a reasonable time, or damaged by the way you used them, do not fail the section 55 standard simply because they no longer work.

The section 56 right is in addition to any manufacturer's or shop warranty and to your common-law rights (section 56(4)). A shop's own "no refunds" policy cannot take it away.

Deadlines

  • Six months from delivery to return the goods under section 56(2). Count from the day you received the goods, not from the day you first noticed the problem.
  • Three months after a repair for the repeat-failure rule in section 56(3).
  • Three years to bring a complaint to the National Consumer Tribunal or a provincial consumer court: section 116(1) says a complaint may not be referred more than three years after the act or omission that caused it.

If the six months have passed, you may still have a claim under section 55 (goods must be durable for a reasonable period) or under an express warranty, but the simple return-and-choose route in section 56(2) no longer applies.

Practical example

Thandi buys a new fridge from an appliance store in Durban. It is delivered on 3 March. In mid-July it stops cooling. She has not moved it or tampered with it. Because the defect appears within six months of delivery, she contacts the store in writing, explains the fault, and states that she chooses a refund under section 56(2). The store offers to send a technician instead. Thandi may refuse that offer. The store must collect the fridge or carry the cost of returning it, and refund the price she paid.

If Thandi had chosen a repair and the fridge failed again for the same reason within three months of the repair, she could then insist on a replacement or a refund under section 56(3).

What to do

  1. Stop using the item if continued use could cause further damage or danger, and keep it in the condition it is in.
  2. Find your proof of purchase and the delivery date (invoice, delivery note, bank statement or order confirmation).
  3. Contact the supplier in writing within six months of delivery. Describe the defect, attach photos, refer to sections 55 and 56(2) of the CPA, and state your choice: repair, replacement or refund.
  4. Return the goods or arrange collection. The return is at the supplier's risk and expense, so ask the supplier to collect large items or to reimburse transport costs.
  5. Keep copies of every message and the names of the people you dealt with.
  6. If the supplier refuses, use the dispute routes in section 69: an accredited industry ombud if the supplier falls under one (for example, motor vehicles), your provincial consumer court, or a complaint to the National Consumer Commission through its e-Services portal. Ordinary courts are a last resort once other remedies are exhausted (section 69(d)).
  7. For a money claim, the Small Claims Court can hear claims up to R30 000 from 1 August 2026, according to the Department of Justice.

When to get a lawyer

Consider legal advice if the item is expensive (for example a car), if the supplier claims you misused the goods, if you signed a document accepting the goods in a specific condition, if you bought as a business, or if you suffered injury or damage to other property because of the defect. Product-liability claims under section 61 of the CPA, where a defective product causes harm, are more complex than a simple return. Legal Aid South Africa and university law clinics can help people who cannot afford a private attorney.

South Africa